Update: Unlike the other companies involved, Benetton is not compensating the families of the victims, so I’m adding them to the list below. If you want to let them know how you feel, tweet to @benetton with the hashtag #PayUpBenetton.(2/9/15)
When Baguette was a newborn, we were very careful about sourcing her toys. We worked hard to buy toys that were made with safe materials, by companies that treated their workers decently.
I will be the first to admit that we have not kept up that vigilance. So I am dismayed to learn that a number of major retailers have decided not to sign the Bangladesh factory safety plan, developed in the wake of a massive, tragic, and wholly preventable building collapse that took the lives of over 1,100 workers.
More than a thousand people. I’m not willing to pay that much for Baguette’s clothing.
Now, the deadline for signing has passed, so it’s not like I can persuade the holdouts to change their minds. That ship has sailed.
But that doesn’t mean that these companies can’t improve working conditions in their factories around the world.
So I’m calling on them to do just that, and here’s who they are:
- Walmart
- Gap
- Macy’s
- Sears/Kmart
- JCPenney
- VF Corp
- Target
- Kohl’s
- Cato Fashions
- Carter’s
- Nordstrom
- American Eagle Outfitters
- The Children’s Place
- Foot Locker
- Benetton
I do not intend to buy any new clothes or accessories from these companies until they ensure safe and humane conditions for the people who make their products–and that they do so transparently, so that we know that they’re using some of their profits to make the world better, and not worse.
For some of these, that’s easy. I can’t tell you the last time I bought something at Foot Locker, and I’m not sure I’ve ever made a purchase at American Eagle Outfitters.
But Carter’s and Gap? That’s tough. I can’t tell you how much I’ve counted on the seasonal sales at my nearest Carter’s store. And Gap? Baguette and I practically live in Old Navy. I’ve been blown away not just by the low prices of their baby and toddler clothes, but by how cute and well-constructed they are. It took me forever to find camisoles that I liked, and they’re sold by Old Navy.
And Target. Don’t get me started on Target. I bought a cardigan there recently, and now I’m wondering if the person who sewed on the buttons is still alive.
Here’s what it comes down to for me: It’s not a good deal if someone has to die. And 1,100 deaths–and that’s just the latest factory disaster–is far, far too high a price to pay.
Who’s with me?
Photo by Martin Abegglen
, via Flickr. Creative Commons.
It seems like it should be so much easier than this. What is wrong with people in charge of companies to see past only profits?! And, I’m surprised by Target, they won me over with their marriage equality registry (and of course, their cardigans) and then this.
i swear, i understand the rules of grammar. you get my drift, though.
I do, indeed. And quite a few of these companies say they’re taking their own precautions–which is fine, but I want them to make those precautions visible to their market.
For sure, I’m with you. This has been on my mind lately. We don’t often factor in the true costs of our cheep goods, and we feel like we’re entitled to a 7 dollar t-shirt. Or, at least that’s the case with me.
There’s no reason that we can’t think about what a garment really costs, and pay the full price. We don’t need to have massive abundance and make the poor pay for it. There’s no reason that we can’t do a little good with the purchases we make. I mean, think of what changes we could see if companies though not about how much money they can make but how much good they could do.
Truth be told, I’ve been working on a project that will put a little good out there in the world.
I look forward to learning about your project!
We have always relied heavily on used clothing, particularly for Baguette; my mother-in-law is a used-baby-clothes-finding genius. So we’ll just do more of that, to a great extent, although I will miss the plethora of cheap Old Navy leggings that she wears every single day.
Pretty much every place we shop is on there. Unbelievable. Like you said, some are easy. But others have been our go-to places for years. Ugh.
I know! And Macy’s has been one of my work-wear sources for several years. I don’t buy a lot there, but it’s where I was planning to go for new office slacks and skirts.
On the plus side, I can look at who DID sign the agreement, and shop there.
Gee, thanks for ruining my day. Every single place I shop for my kids’ clothes (not to mention my own) is on that list, except for the painfully expensive place down the street where I bought two coordinating onesies for the twins that cost more than my car. I guess I can still do eBay.
We’re planning to use eBay ourselves, too!